Value-based Smart Bidding: optimize for margin, not conversion volume

6 min read google-adssmart-bidding
Value-based bidding in Google Ads: how to bid on real customer value and margin, set up conversion values properly and optimize for profit, not volume.

Many accounts still run on “as many conversions as possible”. That feels good, because the dashboard fills up. But ten conversions with €5 in margin each are something very different from two conversions with €100 in margin. Smart Bidding can optimize for value instead of numbers, and that’s exactly where the profit is. In this article I explain how value-based bidding works, what changed recently, and how to set up your conversion values so Google bids on your real customer value.

What is value-based bidding, really?

Smart Bidding is the umbrella term for Google’s automated bid strategies. Within it, there are roughly two flavors. Conversion-based bidding (Maximize conversions, with or without a target CPA) chases as many conversions as possible. Value-based bidding (Maximize conversion value, with or without a target ROAS) chases as much value as possible.

The difference is in what you give Google. With conversion-based bidding, every conversion counts the same. With value-based bidding, you pass a value along with each conversion, and the algorithm optimizes for the sum of those values. A lead form for a €10,000 quote can then carry more weight than a download of a free whitepaper.

The two strategies, briefly

  • Maximize conversion value (without target ROAS): gets as much value as possible within your daily budget. A good fit if your budget is spent every day and your main aim is growth.
  • Maximize conversion value with target ROAS: gets value within an efficiency limit. A good fit if you have a return target and budget isn’t the limiting factor. Work out up front which target ROAS fits your margin.

According to Google, target ROAS needs at least around 15 conversions in the past 30 days at the level of your conversion tracking, and ideally a few weeks of value data before you switch the strategy on. Without that data, the algorithm has too little to learn from.

From ROAS to margin: the real shift

This is where it gets interesting. ROAS looks at revenue per euro of ad spend. But revenue is not the same as profit. Two products with exactly the same ROAS can have completely different margins, and then you want to bid differently on them too.

That’s why the conversation is shifting from ROAS to POAS: profit on ad spend. Instead of revenue, you pass profit or margin as the conversion value. The algorithm then learns by itself to bid higher on products with a fat margin and lower on products that earn very little.

For webshops, Google now offers a direct solution for this. Through conversions with cart data and the cost of goods sold field (cost_of_goods_sold) in your Merchant Center feed, Google can include gross profit in both reporting and bidding. You link Merchant Center to Google Ads, fill in the cost price for each product, and make sure your conversion tracking passes along the items purchased. Per campaign, you then see not just revenue but also gross profit, number of orders and average order value. Cart data is supported for Shopping, Performance Max and search campaigns linked to Merchant Center.

Note that these are signals Google promotes itself, including favorable numbers on profit uplift. Treat those numbers as a direction, not a promise. Your own result depends on your margins, your data quality and how carefully you set it up.

How to set up your conversion values properly

Automation is exactly as good as the values you pass along. “Garbage in, garbage out” applies literally here. These are a few rules I stick to in practice:

Pass real, varied values

For value-based bidding, you need at least two different conversion values. There are two ways to do that: static values (different goals, each with a fixed value) or dynamic values (one goal whose value differs per transaction). For webshops, dynamic values are almost always better, because every order has its own amount.

Optimize for margin, not revenue

Do your margins vary a lot by product or category? Then pass profit instead of revenue. It doesn’t have to be accurate to the cent. If needed, work with margin groups per product category. Even a rough margin correction beats blindly optimizing for revenue.

Value leads by what they bring in

The same principle applies to lead generation. Not every lead is equal. Give a quote request a higher value than a newsletter signup. Even better, connect your CRM so qualified leads and closed deals pass their real value back through offline conversion import. Then Google bids on people who actually turn into paying customers, not on form fills.

Keep your data clean and fresh

Pass your value data as quickly and consistently as possible, ideally daily. The fresher the data, the closer the algorithm can get to optimizing in real time. And keep your tracking in order: duplicate conversions, missing values or a broken tag poison your bids directly.

What this means for you as an advertiser

Concretely, here are a few points to get started with:

  • Decide on your goal first. Do you want growth (Maximize conversion value) or return (target ROAS)? Without a clear goal, you’re not pointing the automation anywhere.
  • Stop blindly optimizing for volume. If your margins differ, conversion volume is a misleading KPI. Switch to value, and to margin where you can.
  • Set up cart data and cost prices if you run a webshop. Fill in cost_of_goods_sold in your Merchant Center feed and turn on conversions with cart data. Then you can really optimize for gross profit.
  • Connect your CRM for lead generation. Import offline conversions, so Google learns from closed deals and not from individual inquiries.
  • Don’t set a new target ROAS too strict. Feel free to start a little below your historical average, give the algorithm room to learn, and then tighten it gradually.
  • Give it time. Expect a few weeks before a value strategy runs stably. Changing settings every day in the meantime backfires.

My position: value-based bidding isn’t a switch you just flip. The gain comes from good conversion values plus a clear goal plus patience. Do that, and Google optimizes for what really matters to you, namely margin and customer value, instead of a full dashboard.

Getting started

Not sure whether your conversion values are right, or are you still running on conversion volume while margin matters more? I’m happy to take a sharp look at your setup.

Free Performance Quick Scan

Sources

Free Quick Scan

Curious what this could bring you?

I review one ad account with read-only access and show you your 3 biggest opportunities. The report is yours to keep.

or book an intro call

Want to win back return?

Start with a Quick Scan and find your 3 biggest opportunities.